A worked example
To keep this concrete, take a hypothetical client. She is a roof plumber who has designed a bracket that clamps a ladder to a gutter. Most ladder stabilisers rest against the gutter. Hers grips the gutter's front lip with a cam that tightens as weight goes onto the ladder, so the harder you climb, the firmer the hold. We'll run her bracket through each question.
1. Can you explain how it works?
A patent protects an invention, not a wish. If all you can say is what the product achieves ("a ladder that can't slip"), you are not there yet. If you can say how it achieves it, you are.
Our plumber can. The cam, the pivot and the way load on the ladder rotates the cam into the gutter lip are a mechanism that someone else could build from her description. That is the threshold. We discuss it further in can you patent an idea?
2. Is it the kind of thing patents cover?
Australian law asks whether an invention is a "manner of manufacture", which in practice means a practical, technical solution that produces a useful result. Products, devices, chemical compositions, manufacturing methods and many computer-implemented systems qualify. Pure business schemes, mathematical formulas, artistic works, mere discoveries of something in nature and the rules of a game generally do not. Human beings and biological processes for generating them are excluded by section 18 of the Patents Act 1990.
A mechanical bracket sits comfortably on the patentable side. The harder cases are software, business methods and food, where the answer depends on where the innovation lies. Our what can be patented page explains those grey areas.
3. Is it new anywhere in the world?
Novelty is judged against everything made public anywhere before your filing date: patents in any country, journal articles, websites, YouTube videos, products on sale and talks given without confidentiality. To fail on novelty, a single earlier document or product has to disclose every essential feature of what you claim.
This is also where inventors most often hurt themselves. If our plumber had posted a video of the bracket on her business's Facebook page last year, that video would count against her. Australia has a 12-month grace period for an inventor's own disclosures, but many important countries do not, so it is a safety net rather than a plan. Our article on patent grace periods country by country explains the differences.
You can do a first check yourself. Our guide on how to find out if your idea is already patented shows you where to look and how to read what you find.
4. Would it be obvious to someone in the trade?
This is the question that decides most patent applications. Even a new invention fails if a skilled person in the field, knowing the common general knowledge and the relevant prior art, would have arrived at it as a matter of routine. Unlike novelty, the examiner may combine two or three earlier documents to argue that your invention is obvious.
Suppose a search turns up ladder stabilisers that hook over a gutter, and separately, cam clamps that tighten under load on scaffolding. An examiner might argue that putting the two together was obvious. The plumber's answer would lie in the detail: perhaps the cam geometry has to be shaped a particular way to work on thin, flexible gutter steel without crushing it, which the scaffolding clamp never had to deal with. Facts like that, and evidence that others in the trade have tried and failed to solve the problem, are what carry an inventive step argument.
Most inventions are combinations of known parts. The question is not whether the parts are new, but whether putting them together that way, to solve that problem, would have been obvious.
5. Does it actually work?
The invention must be useful, meaning it does what the specification says it does. This is a low bar, and in practice it rarely causes trouble for a real product. It catches perpetual motion machines and claims that promise more than the invention delivers. Make sure your description doesn't overstate the results.
What your answers mean
If you can explain how it works, it is the right kind of subject matter, and nothing you have found shows the same thing, you have a realistic candidate for a patent. Most clients end up uncertain on question four, and that is normal. Inventive step is a judgement, and how the application is drafted has a large effect on the outcome. A specification that describes the invention from several angles, with narrower fallback claims built around the features that genuinely differ from the prior art, gives you somewhere to retreat to if the examiner cites something close. We explain how that works in how to read patent claims.
If you fall down on question two, a patent may not be the right tool, and other forms of protection may serve you better. If you fall down on question three because you have already disclosed the invention publicly, talk to an attorney quickly, because the grace period clock is running.
There is a sixth question that the examiner won't ask but you should: is it worth it? A patent is a commercial tool, and its value depends on the market it protects. We look at that in do you need to patent your idea?
Get a second opinion before you commit
A conversation with a patent attorney is the fastest way to test your answers, particularly on inventive step. If you would like a frank view of whether your idea is patentable, contact Patentec for a free initial consultation. We will look at what you have, tell you where the strengths and weak points are, and recommend whether to search, file or rethink.
