How to find out if your idea is already patented

You can check whether your idea has already been patented yourself, for free, in an afternoon. The harder part is knowing what the results mean, because "already patented" can be answering two quite different questions: can you still get a patent, and can you sell your product without infringing someone else's? This guide shows you how to search and how to read what comes back.

Two questions, not one

The first question is patentability. Has anything been published, anywhere in the world and in any form, that discloses your invention? For this purpose it doesn't matter whether an earlier patent is in force, expired or was only ever an application. If it was published, it counts against you.

The second question is freedom to operate. Is there a patent in force, in the country where you plan to sell, whose claims cover what you intend to make? Here status matters a great deal. An expired patent, or one that only ever existed in Germany, cannot stop you selling in Australia.

Inventors often run these together. They find an old patent that looks like their idea and give up, when in fact the patent lapsed fifteen years ago and they are free to make the product, even though they can't patent it. Or they find nothing on a quick search, assume they are clear, and later receive a letter of demand. Keep both questions in mind as you search.

Where to search

Google Patents is the easiest place to start. It covers patent documents from the major offices, translates many foreign documents into English, and lets you search in plain language. Its "Similar documents" and "Cited by" lists are often more useful than the search itself.

Espacenet, run by the European Patent Office, covers more than 150 million documents and groups related filings into families, so you can see where else the same invention was filed. It also shows legal status data for many countries.

AusPat is IP Australia's own database. It is the authoritative record for Australian patents and applications, and the place to confirm whether an Australian patent is in force, lapsed, ceased or expired. WIPO's Patentscope is worth a look for international (PCT) applications.

How to search

Search for what your invention does and how, rather than what you call it. Your "gutter grip" will have been described by someone else as a "ladder stabilising device engaging a roof drainage channel". Write down three or four ways of describing each key feature and try combinations.

Once you find one or two relevant documents, look at their classification codes. Patents are filed under the Cooperative Patent Classification, and searching within the right class code with a few keywords is how professional searchers find documents that use completely different language. Then follow the citations in both directions: the documents your best result cites, and the later documents that cite it.

Don't stop at patents. Search Google Scholar, product listings, YouTube and industry forums. A product sold in the United States ten years ago counts against your patent application just as much as a patent does.

How to read what you find

Start with the drawings and abstract to decide whether a document is relevant at all. For relevant documents, read the claims, which are the numbered paragraphs at the end. The claims define what the patent covers. The description often discusses far more than was ever claimed, and that extra material still counts as prior art for patentability, but only the claims matter for infringement. Our guide on how to read patent claims explains how.

Then check three facts. The first is the date: anything published before your filing date counts against you, however obscure. The second is the country: a patent only has effect where it is granted. The third is the status. Google Patents shows an estimated status, but confirm Australian status on AusPat before relying on it.

A document that describes your idea stops you patenting it, whatever its status. Only a patent that is in force in your market, with claims that cover your product, stops you selling it.

What a search can't tell you

Patent applications are generally published 18 months after they are first filed. Anything filed in the last year and a half is invisible to every database, so a clean search can never rule out a competitor who filed recently.

Keyword searching also misses things. Documents in Chinese, Japanese or Korean are translated by machine, sometimes badly, and an examiner with access to professional databases and classification expertise will often find references that a keyword search never surfaced. Treat your own search as a first look, not a clearance. We discuss its limits further on our is my invention new? page.

If you find something close

Finding prior art is normal and rarely the end of the road. Read the claims and description carefully and write down exactly how your invention differs. If the difference is a real technical one that solves a problem the earlier document didn't, you may still have a patentable invention focused on that difference. If you find a live Australian patent that seems to cover your product, don't launch until you have had its claims reviewed. Sometimes a small design change avoids the claims entirely.

If the stakes justify it, a professional search goes further. A prefiling novelty search looks at the field before drafting, and an international-type search gives you an examiner's opinion on your claims once a provisional is on file. We compare the two in prefiling novelty search vs international-type search.

Let us take a look

If your own search has turned up documents you aren't sure how to read, or turned up nothing and you want a second opinion before you invest, contact Patentec for a free initial consultation. Bring what you found. We can tell you whether it affects your ability to patent, whether it affects your ability to sell, and what a more thorough search would add.

Read next

Prefiling novelty search vs international-type search: which is right for you?
There are two main ways to find out whether your invention is new before you commit to the expensive stages of a patent application. A prefiling novelty search...

Is your idea patentable? Five questions to ask before you file
Whether an idea is patentable comes down to a handful of questions that an examiner at IP Australia will ask about it. You can ask most of them yourself before...

How to read patent claims: broad claims and fallback positions
The claims are the most important part of a patent and usually the hardest to read. They are the numbered sentences at the end of the specification, and they de...