Do you need to patent your idea?

No law says you need a patent to make and sell your invention. A patent is a commercial tool that lets you stop others copying it, and like any tool it suits some jobs and not others. For some inventions it is the single most valuable asset the business will own. For others it costs money and protects very little. The questions below will help you work out which group yours falls into.

What happens if you don't patent it

If you launch without a patent, anyone who sees your product is free to copy how it works. Copyright won't help, because it protects drawings and code, not function. A registered design protects appearance only, so a competitor who makes something that works the same but looks different is in the clear. And once your product is on sale, the chance to patent it is largely gone, because your own launch counts as prior art. Australia gives a 12-month grace period for an inventor's own disclosures, but most of Europe and China do not.

So the decision has a deadline. You need to make it before the product is shown publicly, not after a competitor appears.

Six questions to ask

Would anyone want to copy it?

Patents earn their keep when there is a market large enough for competitors to want a share. A tool for a niche hobby with a few hundred buyers may never attract a copier. A household product that could sell in supermarkets almost certainly will. Be honest about the size of the opportunity, because the value of the patent tracks the value of the market it protects.

Could you tell if someone copied it?

A patent is only useful if you can find and prove infringement. A mechanical product on a shelf is easy: buy one and look at it. A manufacturing process carried out inside someone else's factory is very hard to see. If infringement would be invisible, keeping the invention secret may protect it better, which we discuss in how to choose between a patent and a trade secret.

Will the product still matter in three to five years?

A patent can take several years to be granted, although "patent pending" status starts on the day you file and does deter many copiers. If the product will be obsolete within a year, a patent is unlikely to repay its cost. If it will sell for a decade, the patent has time to work.

Where does your advantage really lie?

Some businesses win on brand, service, speed or relationships, and the invention is a small part of why customers buy. A café's real asset is its name and reputation, which a trade mark protects. A business built around a genuinely new device that does something competitors can't is different. If customers buy because of how the product works, that is what a patent protects.

Do you need investors or licensees?

Investors want to know what stops a larger company copying you once you prove the market. Patent applications are often the answer. If you plan to license the invention rather than make it yourself, a patent is close to essential, because without one there is nothing to license. We cover the options in how to commercialise your patent.

Is it patentable at all?

None of this matters if the invention can't be patented. It must be new, not obvious to someone in the field, and of a kind patents cover. Our article is your idea patentable? walks through those tests.

The right question isn't whether you can get a patent. It is whether the patent will protect something a competitor would want to take, in a way you could enforce.

The middle path

The decision doesn't have to be all or nothing. In Australia, a provisional application secures your priority date and gives you 12 months of patent pending status for a modest outlay. During that year you can test the market, talk to buyers and investors, and learn whether the product has legs. If it does, you proceed to a complete or international application. If it doesn't, you let the provisional lapse. It is never published, so nothing is lost.

That is how most of our clients approach it. Rather than committing to the full cost of international patents at the start, they spend a small amount to keep their options open, and make the bigger decisions with real market information in hand. The provisional still needs to be prepared properly, though, because a thin one secures very little. We explain why in the pitfalls of a poorly prepared provisional patent application.

When we tell clients not to patent

We regularly advise people not to file. Common reasons include an invention that has already been on sale for more than a year, a product whose real advantage is a recipe or process nobody can see from outside, a market too small to justify the cost, and an idea that is genuinely good business but not a technical invention. In those cases we point clients to trade marks, registered designs, confidentiality agreements or simply moving fast, whichever fits.

Not sure? Ask us

Deciding whether to patent is a commercial judgement as much as a legal one, and it helps to talk it through with someone who has seen how these decisions play out. Contact Patentec for a free initial consultation. We will look at your invention and your plans for it, and tell you plainly whether a patent is worth pursuing, and what to do instead if it isn't.

Read next

Is your idea patentable? Five questions to ask before you file
Whether an idea is patentable comes down to a handful of questions that an examiner at IP Australia will ask about it. You can ask most of them yourself before...

How to choose between a patent and a trade secret in Australia
Patents and trade secrets can both protect a competitive advantage, but they work in opposite ways. A patent trades disclosure for a time-limited monopoly, whil...

How to commercialise your patent: a practical guide
Getting a patent granted is an achievement, but on its own a patent earns nothing. The money comes from what you do with it. Commercialisation is where the inve...