Why a bare idea can't be patented
Inventors often ring us with something like "an app that tells you when your bus is full" or "a pram that folds itself". Both are ideas in the sense that they describe a result someone would want. Neither, as stated, tells anyone how to achieve that result.
Patent law has always refused to grant a monopoly over a wish. Under the Patents Act 1990 an invention has to be a "manner of manufacture", which the courts have read as requiring something practical that produces a useful, artificially created result. A patent is also a bargain with the public: you get up to 20 years of exclusivity, and in return you explain your invention well enough that a skilled person could carry it out once the patent expires. A one-line idea gives the public nothing to learn from, so there is nothing to trade.
There is a practical reason too. If the first person to say "a self-folding pram" could own every self-folding pram ever made, nobody else would bother working out a good way to build one.
You cannot patent the result you want. You can patent the particular way you get there, and every reasonable variation of it that you describe.
Where an idea becomes an invention
The line is crossed when you can explain how the thing works. For the pram, that might be a linkage that couples the handle to the wheel frame so that lifting a single latch draws the frame closed under its own weight. For the bus app, it might be a way of estimating passenger load from the ticketing taps and door sensors already on the bus, without adding cameras.
Notice that both explanations are still fairly short. You do not need final dimensions, a materials list or working code. What you need is the mechanism: the parts or steps, how they interact, and why that arrangement produces the result. A patent attorney will then help you broaden it, by asking what else could do the same job, so the claims are not tied to the one version you happened to think of first.
Do you need a prototype?
No. Australia, like most countries, does not require a working model before you file. Many of the provisional applications we prepare are drafted from sketches, notes and a long conversation. What the law does require is that the specification describes the invention well enough for a skilled person to make it. That is a standard of explanation, not of manufacture.
A prototype can still help. Building one often throws up problems and better solutions, and those refinements are worth capturing. But waiting until a prototype is finished before filing can be a mistake if you have been showing the concept around in the meantime. If improvements come along after you file, they can be added later, as we explain in capturing improvements during the provisional period.
The risk of filing too early
The opposite mistake is filing before the idea has become an invention. Someone files a provisional that says, in a page or two, what the product will do, and then spends the next year working out how. The priority date only protects what was actually described at the time. If the mechanism that finally makes the product work isn't in the provisional, it has no priority date, and anything published in the meantime, including your own launch, can be cited against it. We cover this in more detail in the pitfalls of a poorly prepared provisional patent application.
So the sensible order is to work the idea through until you can explain how it works, keep it confidential while you do, and then file before you show it to anyone outside a confidentiality agreement.
What else stops an idea being patented
Even a fully worked-out invention needs to clear the remaining hurdles. It must be new, meaning not disclosed anywhere in the world before your filing date. It must involve an inventive step, so it can't be an obvious tweak to what already exists. And it must fall within patentable subject matter, which excludes things like pure business schemes, mathematical methods and artistic works. We walk through each of these in is your idea patentable?, and the patent requirements page sets out the legal tests.
Protecting an idea that isn't ready yet
If you are still at the idea stage, the most useful protection is confidentiality. Talk to manufacturers, developers and potential partners only under a written confidentiality agreement, and keep dated notes of how the concept develops. Confidentiality won't stop someone who comes up with the same thing independently, but it stops your own conversations from destroying your chance of a patent later.
A trade mark for the product name and a registered design for its appearance may also be worth considering, though neither protects how the product works. Only a patent does that.
Talk to us before you file
Most inventors are closer to a patentable invention than they think. Often a single meeting is enough to turn "I have an idea for" into a description of a mechanism, and to see which parts of it are genuinely new. If you have an idea and aren't sure whether it's ready to protect, contact Patentec for a free initial consultation. We will tell you honestly whether it can be patented yet and what you need to work out first.
