A question we hear often
Every few weeks someone rings us after a trip to a trade fair in Guangzhou or an evening on Alibaba. They have found a product that nobody sells in Australia, ordered samples, and want to patent it before anyone else spots the gap. If you are the first to bring something to the Australian market, it feels as though it should be yours. Patent law sees it differently, for two separate reasons.
Novelty is judged against the whole world
To be patentable, an invention must be new. Under the Patents Act 1990, "new" is measured against what the Act calls the prior art base. That includes information in any document publicly available anywhere in the world, and anything made public by an act done anywhere in the world, such as selling or using the product. A listing on an overseas website, a trade show catalogue, a demonstration video or the product simply being on sale in Germany is enough. It makes no difference that nobody in Australia has seen it, that it was never patented anywhere, or that every document describing it is in Chinese.
It wasn't always this way. For most of the twentieth century, a product that had been used overseas but never described in a document could still be new in Australia. Since 2002, acts done overseas have counted against novelty in Australia just as documents do, and the Raising the Bar reforms of 2013 removed the last local limits from the test for inventive step as well.
If the product exists anywhere in the world, it is prior art. Being first to sell it in Australia is a commercial advantage, not a patentable one.
You are also not the inventor
Suppose the product had never been disclosed at all, say a prototype a factory showed you privately. There is still a second problem. An Australian patent can only be granted to the inventor, or to someone who takes the rights from the inventor, such as an employer or a buyer of the invention. Finding a product and importing it doesn't make you its inventor. A patent granted to the wrong person can be opposed before grant and revoked afterwards.
Examiners search patent literature more thoroughly than product catalogues, so such a patent occasionally slips through. It is worse than none. Anyone you accuse of infringement will find the overseas listing, and threatening a competitor with a patent that won't hold up can leave you facing a claim for unjustified threats under the Act.
Where an importer can get a patent
The opportunity usually lies in what you do with the product after it lands. Importers are well placed to see what's wrong with a product: the customer complaints, the returns, the things that fail in Australian conditions. If you solve one of those problems in a way that isn't obvious, your improvement can be patentable even though the product itself is not.
Take a portable solar shower brought in from overseas. The importer finds that the valve cracks after one summer in the sun, and that the water comes out either scalding or tepid. Making the valve from a UV-stabilised plastic is unlikely to be patentable, because any engineer would think of using a better known material. Changing the colour, the size or the fittings to suit Australian standards falls in the same category. But suppose the importer designs a passive mixing arrangement that draws cooler water from the bottom of the bag in proportion to the temperature at the top, with no electronics. If nothing like that exists in the prior art, which again means anywhere in the world, it may well be patentable.
The question for inventive step is whether the improvement would have been obvious to a skilled person in the field, given the common general knowledge and what has already been published. Improvements that deliver an unexpected benefit, solve a problem others have tried and failed to solve, or combine features so that together they do more than each does alone tend to do well. Our article is your idea patentable? works through these questions in more detail.
What an improvement patent does and doesn't give you
A patent on your improvement lets you stop others making, selling or importing products that use it. It does not stop anyone importing the original product, so a competitor can still bring in the basic solar shower from the same factory. Your edge is that customers will prefer the version that works.
The reverse also applies. A patent gives you a right to exclude others, not a right to sell. If the original product is covered by an Australian patent belonging to the overseas maker, your improved version may still infringe it, and importing is itself one of the acts that infringes. Before committing to stock, check whether the manufacturer holds or has applied for an Australian patent. An international application can still enter Australia up to 31 months from its earliest filing date, so a product with no Australian patent today may have one next year. We explain why this is a separate question from patentability in patent validity vs freedom to operate, and our guide on how to find out if your idea is already patented explains how to search.
Protect the improvement before the factory sees it
The most common way importers lose an improvement is by handing it to the manufacturer. You email the drawings to the factory, and the factory builds your version and offers it to its other customers, or files its own patent application. File a provisional application before the drawings leave your hands, and make sure your supply agreement says that improvements you contribute belong to you. If the factory's engineers help develop the improvement they may be co-inventors, and that needs to be settled in writing. If you keep refining the design after filing, see capturing improvements during the provisional period.
Other ways to protect an imported product
A registered trade mark for your brand is often the most valuable asset an importer builds, because customers come to ask for your name rather than the product (see why you should trade mark). An exclusive distribution agreement with the manufacturer gives you contractual protection against that factory supplying your competitors in Australia, though not against someone sourcing a similar product elsewhere. A registered design can protect a new appearance, but it runs into the same difficulty as a patent: if the product's look has already been published overseas, on the manufacturer's website for instance, it isn't new.
Talk to us before you place the order
If you have found a product to import, or have improved one you already sell, contact Patentec for a free initial consultation. We can tell you whether there is anything in it you can patent, whether someone else's patent stands in your way, and how to protect your brand while you build the market.
