Patent validity vs freedom to operate: two different questions

Clients are often surprised to learn that a granted patent does not give them the right to sell their own product. Whether you can patent something and whether you can sell it without infringing someone else's patent are separate questions. They are answered by different searches, looked at from opposite directions, and a yes to one tells you nothing about the other.

A patent is a right to exclude

The Patents Act 1990 gives a patent owner the exclusive right to exploit the invention, which in practice means the right to stop anyone else making, using, selling, offering, importing or keeping it in Australia without permission. Nothing in the Act gives you permission to do those things yourself. That permission is something you either already have, because nobody else's patent stands in the way, or something you need to obtain.

The usual way the two come apart is through improvements. Suppose a Brisbane company designs a bike rack for cars with a new quick-release clamp that locks onto the tow ball without tools. Nothing like the clamp exists anywhere, so they file and are granted a patent for a rack with that clamp. Meanwhile a competitor holds an Australian patent claiming a bike rack with an arm that folds down against the car when not in use. The Brisbane rack has a folding arm. Their patent is valid, and their rack still infringes the competitor's patent. They can stop others copying their clamp, and the competitor can stop them selling their rack.

Validity asks whether a patent should exist. Infringement asks whether your product falls within someone else's. The answer to one tells you nothing about the other.

Validity: your idea against everything published

Validity, or patentability before grant, asks whether the claims are new and inventive compared with the prior art. The prior art is enormous. It includes every document published anywhere in the world before your priority date, in any language and of any age, along with products sold or used publicly. Expired patents count just as much as live ones, and so do journal articles, product manuals, websites and videos.

In a validity search, everything in a document matters, not just its claims. A drawing buried in a 1970s German patent that shows your clamp is enough to destroy novelty, even though the patent itself was about something else and lapsed decades ago. The question is what the public already knew. This is the search we recommend before drafting a patent application, and our article comparing a prefiling novelty search with an international-type search explains the options.

Infringement: your product against live claims

Freedom to operate looks the other way. The question is whether the product you intend to sell falls within the claims of a patent that is in force in the country where you will be making, selling or importing it. That is a much narrower set of documents, read in a different way.

Only the claims matter. Patents describe all sorts of things in their description and drawings that they do not claim, and anything described but not claimed is free for others to use. To infringe, your product generally has to include every feature of at least one claim, so a single missing feature can be the difference between infringing and not. Our article on how to read patent claims walks through this in detail.

Only live patents matter, and only in the right countries. A patent that has expired, or lapsed because its owner stopped paying renewal fees, can't be enforced. A United States patent with no Australian equivalent doesn't stop you selling here, though it may stop you exporting there. Pending applications need watching, because their claims can still change, and once granted the owner can generally claim damages for infringement going back to the date the application was published.

The two can point in opposite directions

Because the questions are different, all four combinations happen. A product can be patentable and free to sell, which is the best outcome. It can be patentable but infringe an earlier patent, as with the bike rack. It can be free to sell but not patentable, which is the position of anyone copying a product whose patent has expired. Making exactly what an expired patent disclosed is generally safe, because any live claim broad enough to cover it would itself be invalid. And it can be neither, which is the position of an importer bringing in a product that is still under someone's Australian patent, as we discuss in can you patent an imported product?

A patentability search will not reveal infringement risk, and a freedom to operate search will not tell you whether your idea is new. If you only commission one, be clear about which question it answers.

When each search makes sense

A patentability search belongs early, before you spend money drafting an application, so the claims can be aimed at what is genuinely new. A freedom to operate search belongs before you commit serious money to the product: tooling, a production run, a first container of stock, or a product launch. It is a snapshot of the patents in force on the day it is done, so for a long project it is worth repeating before launch.

Freedom to operate searches cost more than many people expect, because each candidate patent has to be read claim by claim against your product and its legal status checked in each country. Narrowing the search to the features you are least sure about, and the countries you will actually sell in, keeps the cost sensible.

If a patent stands in your way

Finding a blocking patent is not always the end. Often the best answer is to design around it by removing or changing one feature of the claim, which is why reading the claims precisely matters so much. You can approach the owner for a licence. You can check whether the patent is really in force, or whether it is close to expiry. And if you believe it should never have been granted, a validity search aimed at that patent may find prior art to challenge it, by re-examination at IP Australia, opposition if it has not yet been granted, or revocation in court. Our page on patent infringement covers what happens if a dispute arises.

Talk to us before you invest

Knowing which question you are asking is half the work. If you are developing a product, or about to commit to stock, contact Patentec for a free initial consultation. We will tell you whether you need a patentability search, a freedom to operate search or both, and what each will cost.

Read next

How to read patent claims: broad claims and fallback positions
The claims are the most important part of a patent and usually the hardest to read. They are the numbered sentences at the end of the specification, and they de...

Prefiling novelty search vs international-type search: which is right for you?
There are two main ways to find out whether your invention is new before you commit to the expensive stages of a patent application. A prefiling novelty search...

Can you patent an imported product?
Usually not. If a product is already made, sold or described anywhere in the world, it isn't new, and no Australian patent can validly be granted for it however...